Silver: the two bets you’re really making

Over a few weeks in December and January, the rand price of an ounce ran from around R700 to nearly R1,900. Then, almost as quickly as it had risen, the price of silver plummeted. Today silver sits near R1,025 an ounce, roughly 46% below that January high.

If you’ve been eyeing silver as a way to hold something real, that drop raises an obvious question: is it cheap now, or is there further to fall?

The answer comes in two halves, and the second half is the one South African investors sometimes forget to think about.

You’re making two bets, not one.

When you buy silver in South Africa, you’re really buying two things at once.

There’s the dollar price of silver, set on global markets, and there’s the rand, which decides how many of your rand each dollar costs. The price you pay, and ultimately the price you sell at, is essentially the product of those two.

Right now silver trades near $64 an ounce in dollars, and the rand sits around R16.20 to the dollar. Put them together and you get roughly R1,025.

Simple enough.

But it means the rand price of silver can move significantly even when silver itself does very little, purely because the rand has strengthened or weakened against the dollar.

This matters enormously for anyone hoping to see that R1,900 record again.

There are two main roads back. Either the dollar silver price climbs towards $118 an ounce, roughly where it peaked in January, or silver manages a more modest recovery to perhaps $90 to $100 while the rand weakens to R19 to R21 against the dollar.

In reality, it would probably be some combination of the two.

What South African investors shouldn’t automatically assume is that the currency will hand them the gain. Currently, the opposite is happening. A relatively strong rand is quietly capping the local silver price even when the international dollar price holds firm.

That currency effect is one of the most important differences between looking at a silver chart in New York and actually owning silver in Johannesburg, Cape Town, or Durban.

What actually happened in January?

It’s worth understanding the madness, because it explains why the chart looks the way it does.

Silver’s spike wasn’t simply a speculative meme trade. Underneath it sat a genuine physical-market story: several years of the world consuming more silver than it produced, declining available inventories, strong investment demand, and increasingly important industrial demand.

Add a soaring gold price and a wave of investors piling into the market, and the move became increasingly difficult to contain.

Then silver ran into a wall.

Futures exchanges raised the amount of collateral required to hold leveraged silver positions. That forced some traders to reduce positions whether they wanted to or not. At roughly the same time, changing expectations around US monetary policy added another source of volatility.

Silver declined by more than 30% in a very short period.

Anyone who bought at the very top learned an old lesson the hard way: silver can move dramatically faster than gold, in both directions.

The deficit is real, but keep it in proportion.

The long-term bull case for silver rests partly on a simple idea.

For several years, the world has consumed more silver than it produces, making up the difference by drawing on existing above-ground inventories.

The Silver Institute has thoroughly documented the real deficit.

But there is an important qualification.

The annual shortfall has been getting smaller rather than larger. It was around 200 million ounces in 2023, approximately 149 million ounces in 2024, and fell sharply during 2025, with a considerably smaller deficit expected again in 2026.

That still matters. A market that repeatedly consumes more than it produces cannot do so indefinitely without some adjustment in price, demand, supply, or all three.

However, this does not imply that the world is on the verge of depleting its silver reserves.

High prices have a way of changing behavior.

One of the clearest examples is solar.

Photovoltaic manufacturing has been one of the world’s largest sources of industrial silver demand, but manufacturers have steadily reduced the amount of silver required in each solar cell. The industry is also actively developing technologies that substitute copper for silver in certain applications.

That doesn’t make solar demand irrelevant to silver. Far from it. But it illustrates something investors should always remember: demand responds to price.

If silver becomes sufficiently expensive, engineers start looking very hard for ways to use less of it.

The other side of the supply equation

There is, however, another structural feature of the silver market that deserves just as much attention.

Silver supply does not respond to rising prices as easily as the supply of many other commodities.

Only a relatively small proportion of global silver production comes from mines whose primary product is silver. Estimates vary from year to year, but roughly 70% to 80% of silver is typically produced as a by-product of mining for metals such as lead, zinc, copper, and gold.

That matters.

If the silver price doubles, a dedicated silver mine has an obvious incentive to increase production. But a copper mine that produces silver as a by-product isn’t necessarily going to increase its copper production just because the metal has become more valuable.

In other words, a large part of the silver supply cannot respond directly to the silver price.

Declining ore grades add another complication. Over time, miners often have to process increasing quantities of rock to recover the same amount of metal, which increases cost and makes meaningful production growth more difficult.

And developing a new mine is neither quick nor simple. Exploration, financing, permitting, construction, and commissioning can take many years.

So while industrial users are finding ways to become more efficient with silver, the supply side has its constraints.

This is one reason we think the more sensible long-term case for silver is not based on dramatic predictions of an imminent shortage. It is based on something more mundane but potentially more durable: steadily growing industrial demand meeting a supply base that is relatively difficult to expand.

And what about copper?

There is an interesting second investment theme emerging from the very process that could reduce silver consumption.

If industries such as solar increasingly substitute copper for silver, they don’t eliminate demand for conductive metals. They shift part of that demand elsewhere.

Copper is already at the center of electrification. Solar installations, electrical grids, electric vehicles, renewable energy systems, data centers, and general infrastructure all require enormous quantities of it.

For South Africans interested in owning physical industrial metals, however, copper presents a very different proposition from gold or silver.

Small decorative copper rounds and coins can carry extremely high premiums relative to the value of the copper they contain. In some cases, the premium can be several hundred percent, which makes them far less attractive as a straightforward metal investment.

A more practical way of gaining physical exposure may be through commercially produced copper busbars or similar high-purity industrial copper products. Depending on the supplier and quantity, premiums can potentially be closer to the underlying metal value, perhaps around 10% rather than the several hundred per cent premiums sometimes attached to novelty copper rounds.

There are trade-offs.

Copper is far less value-dense than silver or gold, so it takes up considerably more space. Storage, transport, and eventual resale also need to be considered carefully. Investors should also establish their likely resale market before buying any large quantity of physical copper.

But as an industrial-metal diversification idea, it is worth understanding.

The same technological shift that potentially reduces one component of silver demand may simultaneously reinforce the long-term demand story for copper.

Silver’s industrial future is broader than solar.

Solar is only part of the silver picture.

Electric vehicles generally require substantially more silver than conventional internal-combustion vehicles. Modern electronics, power distribution, high-performance computing, data centers, and electrical infrastructure all rely on silver’s exceptional electrical and thermal conductivity.

AI might sound like a software story, but underneath it sits a very physical network of servers, switches, power systems, and data centers.

The same applies to electrification.

All of that infrastructure requires metals.

That doesn’t guarantee silver will rise every year. It does, however, provide a structural source of demand that is very different from the speculative investment demand that traditionally drove much of silver’s boom-and-bust cycle.

It argues for a metal that potentially appreciates over years rather than one that necessarily doubles overnight.

Is silver actually cheap?

This is where perspective matters.

When someone says silver is a bargain simply because it is roughly 46% below its recent high, investors should be cautious.

The high itself was almost certainly an overshoot.

An asset isn’t automatically cheap because it has fallen sharply from an unsustainable price.

However, when measured against gold, silver appears to offer somewhat better value.

The gold-to-silver ratio is currently around 68, compared with a long-run level closer to 60. If that relationship gradually returns to historical norms, Silver would need to catch up.

But “reasonably valued” or “modestly undervalued” is very different from “dirt cheap.”

That’s an important distinction.

The psychology of buying after a fall

Today’s market can be viewed from a different perspective.

Warren Buffett famously said:

“Be fearful when others are greedy and greedy when others are fearful.”

The principle isn’t that every falling asset is automatically a bargain. Sometimes prices fall for excellent reasons.

The more useful lesson is that investors should be wary of making their biggest purchases when enthusiasm is at its highest and prices have already run dramatically higher.

Silver sitting roughly 46% below its peak creates a very different risk and reward proposition from buying during the frenzy near R1,900 an ounce.

That doesn’t mean today’s price is the bottom.

Nobody knows where the exact bottom will be.

But for somebody who already believes in silver’s long-term fundamentals, making measured purchases after a substantial correction can be a more disciplined approach than chasing a vertical market at record highs.

The key word is measured.

The near-term outlook and the key levels to monitor are as follows:

The immediate backdrop isn’t entirely Silver’s friend.

Persistent US inflation and resilient economic growth have kept interest-rate expectations elevated. Higher interest rates tend to make non-yielding assets such as precious metals somewhat less attractive relative to interest-bearing alternatives.

That has contributed to the softer tone in silver since the peak.

For a South African investor, however, you once again have to overlay the rand.

A weaker silver price combined with a stronger rand can push the local price down particularly quickly.

Conversely, if silver recovers while the rand weakens, South African investors effectively have both engines working in their favor.

The local chart highlights two levels that warrant attention.

The R900 region is a crucial level on the downside. A decisive break below it would indicate that the correction may have further to run.

On the upside, R1,140 is the first meaningful hurdle. A sustained move through that level would be an early indication that buyers are regaining control.

At around R1,025, silver is sitting almost exactly between the two.

Our take

Silver remains a long-game metal.

The investors who tend to cope best with it are those who understand its volatility, buy in stages, and measure their holding period in years rather than weeks.

There are reasonable arguments on both sides at today’s price.

The deficit isn’t as dramatic as it was a few years ago, and sectors such as solar are learning to use less silver.

But silver’s supply is unusually difficult to expand because most of it is produced as a by-product of other mining. Ore grades are under pressure, bringing new mines into production takes years, and industrial demand from electrification, vehicles, electronics, data centers, and power infrastructure remains substantial.

Investors are not being asked to buy into the euphoria that existed near the peak, as the price is roughly 46% below its recent high.

If you already own silver, there is little in the long-term supply-and-demand picture that automatically argues for selling simply because the price has corrected sharply.

If you’re considering starting or increasing a position, there is equally no prize for buying everything at once.

Building exposure gradually allows you to take advantage if the market weakens further while still participating if the long-term thesis begins to reassert itself.

And for South Africans, always come back to the two-bet idea.

You’re not simply investing in silver.

You’re investing in silver and the rand at the same time.

A roaring international silver market can still produce a disappointing rand return if the rand strengthens significantly, while a fairly ordinary silver market can deliver an excellent local return if the rand weakens.

That’s the quiet second half of the trade, and it’s the half that’s uniquely important to a South African investor.

Disclaimer: This article is provided for general information and educational purposes only and does not constitute financial, investment, or tax advice. African Bullion is a precious metals dealer, not a licensed financial services provider, and nothing here should be taken as a recommendation to buy or sell any asset. Precious metal prices can be volatile and may fall as well as rise, and past performance is no guarantee of future results. Before making any investment decision, please do your own research and consider consulting a licensed financial adviser about your personal circumstances.

Item added to cart.
0 items - R0.00